Discretionary appointment of counsel

Key_development Question_mark

Litigation, All Basic Human Needs

 In Couturier v. Thirteenth Judicial District, OP 11-0459 (Mont. 2011), attorneys for Montana Legal Services appealed the denial of counsel for a mother whose child was subject to a permanent guardianship proceeding (she had originally consented to temporary guardianship, but then sought to revoke her consent prior to establishment of permanent guardianship). The trial court originally refused to appoint counsel on the grounds that it lacked the statutory authority to do so. The Montana Supreme Court twice ordered the trial court to respond to the petitioner's arguments that there is a due process right to counsel. When the trial court failed to do so, the high court ordered the trial court to appoint pro bono counsel for the mother and reminded the trial court that it always has the inherent authority to appoint pro bono counsel in appropriate cases.

Appointment of Counsel: discretionary Qualified: no